This article reviews the top-rated toners specifically formulated for gray, white, and silver hair. We compared toning power, ease of use, conditioning benefits, and price across leading brands like Wella, Clairol, and Schwarzkopf. Whether you want to tone at home or in the salon, we’ve got you covered.
Read on for our picks of the most effective toners for neutralizing brassiness and enhancing radiant, luminous silver strands. We’ll also provide application tips from hair colorists for maximizing results.
MANIC PANIC Silver Stiletto Hair Toner
The MANIC PANIC Silver Stiletto Hair Toner is a semi-permanent hair dye with an icy, lavender-tinted silver color. It acts as a toner to help create platinum hair by eliminating yellow hues. The product is designed to lift hair to 5 levels and cancel yellow tones, preparing your hair for the most intense Manic Panic colors. It contains vegetable protein Castor Oil, which coats and protects the hair during lightening.
The product comes in a 4oz package and is available in various strengths, including maximum, medium, and superpower. It is suitable for medium brown, dark brown, and black hair color (natural) and can help achieve medium blonde to light blonde results. The product is cruelty-free and vegan, with key ingredients like Castor Oil and quinoa, Coconut Oil, and Sunflower Seed Extract.
The product has been reviewed positively for its vibrant color, vegan and cruelty-free formula, and ability to donate to charities with each purchase. However, some users have noted that the color’s longevity could be improved and that the application can be tricky due to the thin consistency of the dye.
The MANIC PANIC Silver Stiletto Hair Toner is part of a larger collection of 49+ shades, all of which are vegan-friendly, paraben-free, gluten-free, ammonia-free, resorcinol-free, PPD-free, phthalate-free, and made in the USA. The product lasts 4-6 weeks on pre-lightened hair and glows under blacklight.
Wella ColorCharm Permanent Liquid Hair Toner, Neutralize Brass
The Wella ColorCharm Permanent Liquid Hair Toner is a highly-rated product designed to neutralize brassiness in blonde hair. The toner, which comes in the shade T14 Pale Ash Blonde, uses Liquifuse Technology to create pure double-process blonde hair color results. It effectively removes the remaining “brass” for perfect blondes every time.
The gentle product is described as an extra mild toner that evenly tones pre-lightened hair. It is recommended to mix one part toner with two parts 20 volume developer and leave it on for up to 30 minutes for optimal results.
Amazon sells the product, and is available for immediate shipping. It is priced at $7.83 and has been positively reviewed by many customers who have found it easy to apply and effective at achieving the desired results. Some users have noted the product has a strong smell, but the reviews are overwhelmingly positive overall.
The product is manufactured by Coty Inc. under the brand name WELLA Color Charm and is made in Mexico. It is ranked #779 in Beauty & Personal Care and #22 in Hair Color on Amazon. The product dimensions are 1.85 x 0.94 x 3.66 inches, weighing 2.1 ounces.
Pravana Chromasilk Express Tones – Smokey Silver, 3 Oz (I0097559)
Pravana Chromasilk Express Tones – Smokey Silver, 3 Oz (I0097559) is a semi-permanent hair color product designed to create natural tones and add maximum shine. This product is part of Pravana’s ChromaSilk Express Tones line, known for its gentle, ammonia-free toners that leave hair feeling healthier and shinier in under five minutes. The product comes in 14 intermixable, high-shine shades.
The Smokey Silver variant is prevalent for achieving high-shine, rich, lower-level deposits on levels 7 and below. It takes only 5 to 15 minutes at the shampoo bowl to create three all-new, long-lasting tones. The unique, progressive deposit means the tones darken the longer they’re left to process. This product also has multi-use capabilities that allow for lowlighting, shadow roots, filling, enhancing or diminishing tones, and more.
The product has received positive user reviews, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars from 737 ratings. Users have praised the product for its easy application, fast-acting formula, and the beautiful, shiny results it delivers. However, some users have noted that the product may not show the exact tone they were hoping for, suggesting that results may vary depending on individual hair types and colors.
The product is sold in a 3 oz tube, which users have appreciated for its value for money. It is available for purchase on Amazon, where it is frequently bought together with other Pravana products such as Pravana Chromasilk Express Tones – Violet, 3 Oz (I0097552) and PRAVANA Zero Lift Color Activator by Pravana.
Got2b Metallic Permanent Hair Color, M71 Metallic Silver
The Got2b Metallic Permanent Hair Color, M71 Metallic Silver by Schwarzkopf, is a hair dye that offers a multi-dimensional metallic look. It promises head-turning radiance and an anti-fading effect for a permanent hair color that lasts. The product is formulated with a metallic shine booster to deliver excellent, shimmering tones.
The package includes a tube of color cream, an application bottle with developer lotion, a tube of color after treatment, a pair of gloves, and an instruction leaflet. For those with hair longer than shoulder length, it’s recommended to use two boxes of the product for the application.
The product works best on bleached and light blondes; its cream consistency makes it easy to apply. However, it’s important to note that the product can cause an allergic reaction in rare cases. So, precautions should be taken, including performing a skin allergy test 48 hours before each use.
The product has received mixed reviews from customers. Some users have praised the product for its effectiveness and the unique metallic shades it delivers, while others have reported that the color did not last as long as they expected or did not achieve the desired shade. The product is rated 3.9 out of 5 stars based on 6,811 global ratings.
Schwarzkopf Professional Igora Royal Absolutes Silverwhite – Silver
Schwarzkopf Professional Igora Royal Absolutes Silverwhite – Silver is a hair color treatment designed to enhance the natural shade of white hair with a subtle silver sheen. The product offers a soft and delicate result, emphasizing the beauty of your natural hair color and perfecting your shade of silver. It can transform yellowish, matte hair into a silky, shining silver lasting up to twenty-five washes.
The product comes in a 60 ml / 2.0 fl. oz. package and includes an additional care treatment combined with a color enhancement that takes ten minutes. Schwarzkopf Professional offers a second application for customers who want an even softer result. This involves adding silver to the customer’s Tonal Refiner, which reduces the intensity of the shade and gives a soft silver sheen in twenty minutes.
The range is available in four shades: Silver, Dove Grey, Slate Grey, and Grey Lilac. The transparent effect brings out the natural silver sheen and grows out virtually seamlessly at the hairline. At the same time, the silica mine and collagen complex build up the hair, restoring its youthful freshness.
Seven Inc and ships from Amazon Fulfillment sell the product. It is eligible for return, refund, or replacement within 30 days of receipt. The product has received a 3.9 out of 5 stars based on 328 ratings. However, some customers have reported issues with the packaging, stating that it arrived damaged.
Ion 7SP-HM Silver Pearl Permanent Creme Hair Color 7SP-HM Silver Pearl
The Ion Permanent Creme Hair Color 7SP-HM Silver Pearl is a high-quality hair color product that offers an extensive range of shades, including beautiful brunettes, cool blondes, and rich reds. This product is vegan, cruelty-free, and PPD-free, ensuring it’s safe for use and environmentally friendly.
The Ion hair color science utilizes the power of micro-pigmentation, where microscopic pigment molecules oxidize slower, allowing them to penetrate deep into the cortex of each hair strand. This results in a long-lasting, fade-resistant color. The product also guarantees 100% gray coverage as it penetrates the cuticle layer of the hair and lodges in the cortex.
The Ion Permanent Creme Hair Color is gentle on the hair, containing up to 38% less ammonia than other leading professional brands. Its formulas are enriched with hyaluronic acid, argan oil, pequi oil, and botanicals to nourish and strengthen hair from within.
This product has received positive user reviews, with many praising its vibrant color, longevity, and ease of application. It is available on Amazon, with the option for return, refund, or replacement within 30 days of receipt.
OGX Blonde Enhance + Purple Toning Drops, Blonde Toning to Personalize Your Blonde, Silver, Pre-lightened, Natural Blonde Hair
OGX Blonde Enhance + Purple Toning Drops is a highly pigmented formula designed to enhance the color of blonde, silver, pre-lightened, or natural blonde hair. This product is ideal for those who can’t make frequent salon visits but want to maintain their hair color’s vibrancy and brightness. It works by correcting yellow tones in the hair, thereby protecting it from color fade.
The toning drops are enriched with keratin, purple fig, and iris, which tone the hair and nourish it, giving it a fresh and vibrant look. The versatile product can be added to any shampoo, conditioner, or cream-based styling product. For optimal results, it is recommended to use 3-5 drops 1-2 times per week. The longer the product is left on the hair, the more pronounced the toning effect will be.
One of the key features of this product is its ability to personalize the tone of your hair. You can adjust the number of drops according to your desired level of toning. This makes it a perfect choice for those who want to experiment with different shades of blonde.
Customer reviews indicate that the product is easy to use and effective in reducing brassiness. Some users have noted that they’ve seen improvements even after the first use. However, some customers mentioned they needed more than the recommended drops to achieve their desired results. OGX Blonde Enhance + Purple Toning Drops is a popular choice for maintaining and enhancing blonde hair at home.
Keracolor Conditioner Hair Dye
The Keracolor Conditioner Hair Dye is a semi-permanent hair color depositing conditioner with 20 colors. It is cruelty-free and retails for $22.00 per bottle, which equates to $1.83 per fluid ounce. Amazon.com sells the product and is eligible for return, refund, or replacement within 30 days of receipt, provided it is returned in its original condition.
The product is designed to infuse color into the hair with every wash, maintaining vibrancy and adding stunning hues between salon visits. It is recommended for use after fresh paint to maintain energy. For application, a generous amount should be applied and combed through for even saturation before rinsing thoroughly.
The Keracolor line is infused with Keratin, which conditions, strengthens, smooths, and nourishes the hair with each use. This product is from a small business brand, supporting Amazon’s commitment to empowering small businesses.
The product has received positive reviews, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars from over 80,000 ratings. Customers have praised the product’s ability to add color without damaging the hair and its pleasant smell. However, some customers have noted that the product requires regular maintenance to keep the color vibrant.
Keracolor manufactures the product in the USA, and it is not discontinued. It comes in a 1.77 x 1.77 x 6.69-inch bottle, weighing 12.7 ounces. The item model number is 6800308. The product ranks #173 in Beauty and Personal Care, #1 in Hair Color Glazes, and #5 in Hair Color on Amazon.
L’Oreal Paris Feria Multi-Faceted Shimmering Permanent Hair Color Hair Dye, S1 Smokey Silver
The L’Oreal Paris Feria Multi-Faceted Shimmering Permanent Hair Color Hair Dye, S1 Smokey Silver, is a high-quality hair dye product with a unique and vibrant color spectrum. This product is designed to deliver intensified, brilliant results with its shimmering smokey silver color and 3X highlights. The formula is custom-blended by L’Oreal’s master colorists and features an array of bold shades inspired by the latest fashion trends.
The product kit includes a Conditioning Colour, Crème, Conditioning Developer Crème, Aromatic Shimmer Serum, and Power Shimmer Conditioner. These components seal and smooth the hair, ensuring it never appears dull or flat. The product is safe for pre-lightened hair and has been praised for its easy application and impressive results.
L’Oreal Paris Feria also offers a range of other hair color products, including permanent, semi-permanent, and temporary hair dyes, root cover-ups, anti-brass toners, and lightening systems. These products are designed to cover gray hair, highlight, or provide bold, bright color.
The product has received positive reviews from customers who have used it, with many praising its ability to deliver vibrant, long-lasting color and its nourishing formula that leaves hair feeling soft and healthy. Some users have also noted that the product provides excellent gray coverage and is gentle on the hair.
Overall, the L’Oreal Paris Feria Multi-Faceted Shimmering Permanent Hair Hair Dye, S1 Smokey Silver, is a highly recommended product for those seeking a bold, fashionable hair color that nourishes and conditions the hair.